Plumb

Find reviews of an iPhone

Who reviews an iPhone, and can you trust them?

Plumb does not review an iPhone itself. We tell you which sites do, and grade each on the one thing that decides whether to believe it: how independent and evidence-based the ranking is.

Grade Review site Independence30%Evidence basis30%Method transparency20%Conflict disclosure10%Manipulation resistance10%
1 A+
Consumer Reports High Scoring Confidence Partly paywalled Hands-on tester
Grades: the products it buys and lab-tests
The benchmark. Buys what it tests, takes no ads, answers to members.
55455
2 A+
Tom's Hardware High Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester
Grades: its lab-benchmarked PC-component reviews
An in-house lab that benchmarks PC hardware hands-on and says it won't sell reviews; the buy buttons earn it affiliate commissions, and it says so at the top of the review.
45554
3 A
Notebookcheck High Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester
Grades: its lab-tested laptop and phone reviews
A lab-driven laptop and gadget reviewer that publishes its own measurements and method; it earns affiliate commissions and ad revenue, and the same arm that sells its advertising also arranges the review samples.
45535
4 A
RTINGS High Scoring Confidence Partly paywalled Hands-on tester
Grades: its lab-tested scores for TVs, headphones, and monitors
The most transparent lab testing on the web, now partly behind a paywall and wrapped in affiliate links.
35545
5 A
PCWorld High Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester
Grades: its lab-tested PC and laptop reviews
A staff-written tech publication that does real hands-on lab testing and publishes its method; it earns affiliate commissions on what you buy but, by its own disclosure, does not sell reviews or placement to vendors.
45444
6 A
Trusted Reviews High Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester
Grades: its lab-tested consumer-tech reviews
A hands-on UK tech-review site that tests gear in its own labs and says it never takes money to review; just remember the buy-links next to each verdict earn it affiliate commissions.
45444
7 A
GSMArena High Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester
Grades: its standardized phone reviews and specs
A specs-and-reviews institution that tests phones hands-on in its own lab with published methods; it earns from ads and affiliate links, but by its own disclosure those don't touch the editorial reviews.
45533
8 A
DPReview High Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester
Grades: its standardized camera and lens test reviews
A rare reviewer that earns its authority: in-house, hands-on camera tests against a published, reproducible studio scene, with paid content kept separate and labeled.
35544
9 A-
The Verge High Scoring Confidence Partly paywalled Editorial reviews
Grades: its hands-on tech reviews and scores
Hands-on tech journalism with real testing and disclosed affiliate links; by its own policy, commissions and ads don't dictate scores, but review depth varies by category.
45344
10 A-
Wirecutter High Scoring Confidence Partly paywalled Hands-on tester
Grades: its single 'best' pick per product category
Real testing behind an affiliate paywall of conflict. Good work, mixed incentives.
35444
11 A-
Digital Trends High Scoring Confidence Editorial reviews
Grades: its 5-star tech reviews and buying guides
A long-running hands-on tech reviewer with a published testing method, but its "best of" picks ride on the same affiliate links it earns commissions from, which it discloses.
35444
12 A-
PCMag High Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester
Grades: its lab-tested reviews and 'Editors' Choice' awards
Genuine lab tests up top, retailer-paid 'where to buy' links underneath.
35434
13 B+
TechGearLab (GearLab) Medium Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester
Grades: Consumer electronics and fitness gear (fitness trackers, running watches, headphones, smart home devices, tools, kitchen appliances)
TechGearLab's self-purchase, no-free-units policy meaningfully insulates its rankings from vendor influence, but affiliate commissions on every ranked link create a latent incentive toward commercially available products, and the proprietary scoring methodology is not published in reproducible detail.
44344
14 B+
Tom's Guide High Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester
Grades: its hands-on reviews and buying guides for tech
Hands-on consumer-tech reviews from in-house labs that earn affiliate commissions on what they recommend, not placement fees from the brands they rank.
25444
15 B+
Engadget High Scoring Confidence Editorial reviews
Grades: its 1-100 editor reviews of gadgets
A veteran tech publication that hands-on tests gadgets with a published ethics statement, while earning affiliate commissions on the products it recommends.
25444
16 B+
What Hi-Fi? High Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester
Grades: its hands-on hi-fi and AV star ratings
A genuine hands-on testing operation with real test rooms and walled-off ad sales; just remember it earns affiliate commission on the gear it rates highly, which it discloses.
25444
17 B+
Wareable Medium Scoring Confidence Editorial reviews
Grades: Fitness trackers, smartwatches, and health/wellness wearables — individual product reviews and curated best-of ranking lists.
A credible specialist publication with published testing methodology and an explicit editorial-commercial separation promise, but affiliate commissions, display ads, and brand-sponsored content on the same pages create the standard tensions of ad-supported tech media — readers get real hands-on testing, not an arm's-length judgment.
34444
18 B
TechRadar High Scoring Confidence Editorial reviews
Grades: its star-rated reviews and 'best of' buying guides for tech
Helpful buying guides built around the buy links that actually pay the bills.
24444
19 B
BestReviews High Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester
Grades: its lab-tested 'Best of the Best' picks
Hands-on "best of" product picks from a real Nevada testing lab, monetized through affiliate links and syndicated across Nexstar's local TV newsrooms; it says vendors can't buy placement.
34343
20 B
Polygon High Scoring Confidence Editorial reviews
Grades: its game and entertainment reviews
A hands-on games and pop-culture site whose first-hand reviews are credible, but it grades creative works, not the vendors it covers, and critics warn its new owner Valnet rewards SEO clicks over depth.
44223
21 B
GameSpot High Scoring Confidence Editorial reviews
Grades: its hands-on game reviews scored on 10
Hands-on staff reviews on a transparent 10-point scale, but it's an ad- and affiliate-funded outlet, and its independence was famously tested by the 2007 Gerstmann firing, which Gerstmann later said stemmed from advertiser pressure.
24434
22 B-
Good Housekeeping High Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester
Grades: its Institute lab tests and the GH Seal
Real lab testing behind the reviews, but its famous Seal is, by its own program rules, tied to advertising in the magazine.
24334
23 C+
CNET High Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester
Grades: its hands-on reviews and 'best' lists for consumer tech
Real tech testing, but an affiliate model and a recent AI-content credibility hit.
23333
24 C+
IGN High Scoring Confidence Editorial reviews
Grades: its hands-on game reviews and scores
Mostly big-budget games scored above 7, with buy links that double as the business model.
24223
25 C+
Top Ten Reviews High Scoring Confidence Editorial reviews
Grades: its 'top ten' lists and buying guides
A long-running "best of" buying-guide site that does real hands-on testing for some categories, but by its own disclosure earns affiliate commissions on the products it ranks.
23342
26 C-
SolarReviews High Scoring Confidence Crowd reviews
Grades: its consumer-review rankings of solar installers
Useful consumer-review hub for solar, but it earns its money selling leads to the same installers it lists, and critics call it a lead-gen site first.
12332
27 C-
Reviews.org High Scoring Confidence Editorial reviews
Grades: its phone, internet, and TV provider rankings
Carrier reviews from a site owned by a company that, by its own portfolio, is paid to market and generate leads for many of the carriers it ranks.
13222
28 A
AnandTech High Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester Closed / dormant
Grades: its deeply benchmarked hardware reviews
Once the gold standard for exhaustive hardware benchmarking, AnandTech shut down in 2024 after 27 years; in 2025 its articles were pulled and the domain now redirects to its forums, so treat any AnandTech review as a historical archive, not current guidance.
45525
29 A
Reviewed (USA Today) High Scoring Confidence Hands-on tester Closed / dormant
Grades: its lab-tested 'best of' product guides
A genuine hands-on lab-testing operation that Gannett wound down in 2024; its picks were earned, not sold, but a 2023 disclosure lapse (by the company's own admission) and the shutdown leave a static, aging archive.
45434
30 B-
ConsumerSearch Medium Scoring Confidence Score aggregator Closed / dormant
Grades: its 'best reviewed' picks distilled from other reviews
A pioneering "review of the reviews" aggregator that ranked products by reading other experts' tests rather than running its own, and now appears effectively shuttered as its parent's Ask.com sister site has closed.
33323

These are the sites that review an iPhone (and the rest of the consumer electronics). Columns are the five rubric dimensions, scored 0-5, with each column's weight shown in its header (independence and evidence carry the most). See the full methodology.

All consumer electronics → | Find another product or service