Plumb

Compare · Employers & jobs

Who reviews employers & jobs, and can you trust them?

What it's like to work somewhere, from the people who do. Here is every review site we track in this category, graded head to head.

Grade Review site Independence30%Evidence basis30%Method transparency20%Conflict disclosure10%Manipulation resistance10%
1 C+
InHerSight Medium Scoring Confidence Crowd reviews
Grades: its women's ratings of employers
Anonymous women's workplace reviews turned into star ratings and "Best Companies" lists — useful first-hand signal, but the rated employers are also the paying customers, and by its own disclosure the scoring method isn't fully published.
23323
2 C
Blind Medium Scoring Confidence Crowd reviews
Grades: its verified-employee anonymous company commentary
A verified-employee anonymous forum that's candid by design, but it's a discussion board, not a vetted-review system — and Blind itself sells employers recruiting and visibility products alongside the conversation.
33212
3 C
Indeed High Scoring Confidence Crowd reviews
Grades: its employee company ratings
A jobs giant where companies are ranked partly by what they pay: employers buy higher placement for listings, while company "reviews" come from anyone who claims they worked there.
23232
4 C
kununu High Scoring Confidence Crowd reviews
Grades: its anonymous employer ratings (German-speaking Europe)
Europe's Glassdoor: anonymous employee reviews that are useful in aggregate, but the same company that ranks employers also sells them branding profiles, and critics say that creates pressure on neutrality.
23222
5 C
Glassdoor High Scoring Confidence Crowd reviews
Grades: its anonymous employee ratings and 'Best Places to Work'
Anonymous employee reviews can surface real signal, but the same employers being rated pay Glassdoor for branding and recruiting, and critics question how reliably solicited or pressured reviews get filtered out.
13323
6 C
Comparably Medium Scoring Confidence Crowd reviews
Grades: its culture and pay ratings and 'Best Places to Work' awards
Free, employee-driven "Best Places to Work" awards that double as a sales funnel: the badges are won on anonymous employee ratings, but Comparably's owner ZoomInfo sells the employer-branding tools to promote them.
13322

Columns are the five rubric dimensions, scored 0-5, with each column's weight shown in its header; independence and evidence carry the most, 30% each. See the full methodology. Each row also shows a scoring-confidence chip (how sure we are of that grade) and a type tag; hover any chip for what it means.

← All categories